Fraud charges in Florida are almost always felonies, and many carry minimum prison terms once the dollar amount or the number of victims crosses a line. They are also built on proof of what you knew and what you intended, which is where a defense lawyer gets to work. This page covers forgery and uttering, identity theft, credit card fraud, scheme to defraud, insurance fraud, and public assistance and unemployment fraud. The consultation is free.
What are forgery and uttering?
Forgery is falsely making, altering, forging or counterfeiting a listed document with intent to injure or defraud. The list is long: public records, certificates of a clerk or notary, deeds, wills, bonds, powers of attorney, insurance policies, promissory notes, and receipts for money or property, among others. Uttering is publishing a forged document as true, knowing it is forged, with the same intent. Each is a third-degree felony, with up to five years in prison and a $5,000 fine.
The two charges are often filed together, but they are not the same. A person who passed a document without making it can be convicted of uttering only if the State proves he knew it was forged.
What is identity theft under Florida law?
The charge is fraudulent use of personal identification information. It covers a name, date of birth, Social Security number, driver license number, bank account or credit or debit card number, and more. It is a third-degree felony to willfully and without authorization fraudulently use that information, or to possess it with intent to fraudulently use it, without the person’s consent.
The penalties go up quickly:
- $5,000 or more, or 10 to 19 victims. Second-degree felony with a 3-year mandatory minimum prison term.
- $50,000 or more, or 20 to 29 victims. First-degree felony with a 5-year mandatory minimum.
- $100,000 or more, or 30 or more victims. 10-year mandatory minimum.
Other things raise the degree: a victim under 18 or 60 or older, a disabled adult, a public servant, a veteran, a first responder, or a state or federal employee; a deceased victim; using a public record to commit the offense; or pretending to be a police officer or a bank or credit company employee. A conviction also carries a $1,001 surcharge, even with a withhold of adjudication, and the court cannot waive it. Restitution can include the victim’s costs and attorney’s fees for clearing their credit.
The prosecutor can ask the court to reduce or suspend a sentence for substantial assistance in prosecuting others. That is the State’s decision, not the court’s.
What are the credit card fraud charges?
Florida has several. Which one you face depends on what you did with the card.
- First-degree misdemeanor, up to a year in jail: taking a card without consent, receiving one knowing it was taken, keeping a lost or misdelivered card with intent to use or sell it, buying or selling a card, or signing someone else’s card with intent to defraud.
- Third-degree felony: receiving two or more cards issued to different people within 12 months, card forgery (including having a counterfeit card), or knowingly possessing a stolen credit or debit card with intent to keep the owner from getting it back.
Using a card to obtain something of value, with intent to defraud, is a first-degree misdemeanor if it happens two or fewer times in six months and the value is under $100. More than two uses, or $100 or more, makes it a third-degree felony. Debit card cases can also be charged as identity theft, because the statute lists debit card numbers as personal identification information.
What is a scheme to defraud?
The statute is the Florida Communications Fraud Act. A scheme to defraud is a systematic, ongoing course of conduct with intent to defraud, or to obtain property by false pretenses, false representations, or willful misrepresentations of a future act. One bad deal is not automatically a scheme.
If the scheme obtains property, the charge is organized fraud, graded by the total value taken from everyone in the scheme: under $20,000 is a third-degree felony, $20,000 to under $50,000 is second-degree, and $50,000 or more is first-degree. The State can also charge communications fraud for each communication made to obtain property, and the court may impose a separate sentence on each count and on the organized fraud count. A single scheme can turn into many felony counts.
If the victim is 65 or older, a minor, or a person with a disability, the offense moves up one degree.
What is insurance fraud?
It is presenting or preparing a statement in support of an insurance claim or application, with intent to injure, defraud or deceive an insurer, knowing it contains false, incomplete or misleading information about a material fact. Concealing a material fact on an application counts too. The degree follows the value: under $20,000 is a third-degree felony, $20,000 to under $100,000 is second-degree, and $100,000 or more is first-degree.
Motor vehicle claims have their own offenses. Soliciting accident victims with intent to defraud, and organizing or knowingly taking part in a staged crash, are second-degree felonies with a 2-year mandatory minimum. A conviction in a motor vehicle insurance case also brings a civil penalty. A health care provider convicted of a PIP-related fraud loses the license for five years. A contractor who rebates an insurance deductible with intent to defraud commits a third-degree felony.
What are public assistance and unemployment fraud?
Public assistance fraud covers failing to disclose a material fact, or a change in circumstances, to get or keep benefits you are not entitled to. It also covers misusing a food assistance card or Medicaid card, trafficking EBT benefits (buying, selling or exchanging them for cash or anything other than eligible food), and billing fraud by providers. The degree depends on the total value in any 12 months: under $200 is a first-degree misdemeanor, $200 to under $20,000 is a third-degree felony, $20,000 to under $100,000 is second-degree, and $100,000 or more is first-degree. Paying the money back is not a defense.
Reemployment assistance (unemployment) fraud is knowingly making a false statement or hiding a material fact to get or increase benefits. It is a third-degree felony, and each false statement or nondisclosure is a separate offense. Employers can be charged for false statements made to reduce benefits or avoid contributions.
In both kinds of cases, the State leans on records: transaction histories, applications, and payment records count as prima facie evidence that the benefits were claimed and received.
What defenses are there?
These cases are about proof, and the statutes tell me where to look. Did the client know the document was forged, the card unauthorized, or the statement false? Was there intent to defraud, as opposed to a mistake, a misunderstanding or a business deal that failed? Was the fact material? Did the cardholder or account owner consent? Who actually used the card, filed the claim or made the call? Is the dollar amount or victim count right, since that decides the degree and the mandatory minimum? Is the “scheme” a systematic course of conduct or one event? I read the records, the video and the bank and agency files before I tell anyone where their case stands.
For many third-degree felonies, including most of the charges on this page, a person with 22 or fewer total sentence points must be sentenced to a nonstate prison sanction unless the judge makes written findings that it could endanger the public.
What should I do right now?
Do not talk to the investigator, the bank, the insurer or the agency about what happened. Do not delete anything. Keep every letter, notice and subpoena. Call me early, because the sooner I see the records, the more I can do.
Sealing and expunction. A conviction for a violation of the Florida Communications Fraud Act, which is the scheme to defraud statute described above, cannot be sealed or expunged, even if adjudication was withheld. A charge that was never filed, was dismissed, or ended in acquittal is treated differently. See expungement and record sealing.
Common questions
Is the consultation free?
Yes. Call me at (813) 228-6001 and we can talk about the charge and what comes next. The consultation is free.
Should I talk to the police or the investigator?
Please don’t. Call me first. Anything you say can be used to prove knowledge and intent, which are the two things the State needs most.
What should I bring to the consultation?
Whatever you have: the arrest papers or notice of charges, any subpoena or letter from an investigator, bank or card statements, claim forms or applications, and texts or emails about the transactions. If you don’t have them yet, call anyway.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different. Past outcomes do not guarantee a similar result.
The law (short version): Fla. Stat. 831.01, 831.02, 817.568, 817.60, 817.61, 817.67, 817.034, 817.234, 414.39, 443.071, 775.082, 775.083.
The Law Office of Adam B. Landeen, PA
2511 W. Columbus Dr., Tampa, FL 33607
(813) 228-6001
Related: theft and property crimes, robbery, and probation violation.
