Skip to content
Serving Hillsborough, Pinellas & Pasco · Free consultation 813-228-6001
Book a Consultation

A Withhold Doesn’t Mean You Can Expunge It

A lot of people leave court with a withhold of adjudication and think they’ve been handed a clean slate. The judge didn’t find you guilty on paper, so the case must come off your record whenever you’re ready. It doesn’t work that way, and I’d rather you hear it from me now than find out at a background check.

A withhold is a real benefit. The court decided not to formally label you guilty. But the arrest and the case are still on your record, and Florida treats a withhold differently than most people expect.

There are two ways to clear a record in Florida. Expunction destroys it. Sealing hides it. Expunction is open only when the case ended with no charge filed, a dismissal, or an acquittal. A withhold doesn’t fit. What a withhold case can usually do is get sealed. If it stays sealed for ten years, you can then ask the court to expunge it.

Sealed does not mean gone. Law enforcement can still see a sealed record, and so can certain employers and licensing agencies, such as schools, child care, some state agencies, and The Florida Bar. A sealed record also has to be disclosed for a gun purchase from a dealer or a concealed weapon license.

A few other rules catch people:

  • You generally get one sealing or expunction in your lifetime, with a narrow exception for expunging a record that was sealed for ten years.
  • A prior adjudication of guilt can disqualify you. I look at your entire history, including cases from other states, before anything gets filed.
  • Some charges can never be sealed or expunged if you were convicted, and a plea with a withhold counts as a conviction for this purpose. Robbery, drug trafficking, burglary of a home, domestic violence battery, and serious sex offenses are on that list.
  • Even if you qualify, the judge doesn’t have to say yes.

One more thing matters most. You sign a sworn statement saying you meet the requirements. If you leave out an old case, even one you’d forgotten, that statement can turn into a felony of its own. I’d rather we check every case you’ve ever had before anything gets filed.

If your case was dismissed or never filed, you may be able to skip the waiting and go straight to expunction. If you got a withhold, there’s usually a path, just a longer one.

Start by gathering the arrest paperwork, the case number, and whatever shows how the case ended. If you don’t have those, call anyway and we’ll find out what the record shows. The consultation is free. Call me at (813) 228-6001, or read more on my expungement and record sealing page.

This post is general information, not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Call Now Free Consultation